Nestled in the heart of Old Town Windermere, this exceptional lakefront residence offers direct access to the Butler Chain of Lakes from the tranquil waters of Wauseon Bay, prized for its reduced boat traffic and peaceful setting. Set on an oversized waterfront lot with western exposure, the home captures breathtaking lake views from nearly every room—delivering spectacular sunsets and a seamless indoor-outdoor lifestyle. Over 4800sq 5 bedrooms, 4 full bathrooms, Recently enhanced by renovations completed in 2020, the residence now features a newly added owner’s retreat with spa-inspired bathroom, thoughtfully designed to maximize comfort, privacy, and sweeping lake views. Additional updated interior in 2022 showcases refined craftsmanship and high-end finishes, including Provenza engineered hardwood flooring, vaulted tongue-and-groove ceilings, cedar beams, updated bathrooms, custom drapery, and plantation shutters. The large open kitchen is designed for both everyday living and entertaining, featuring 42-inch cabinetry, two oversized kitchen islands, a GE Profile refrigerator, and an Advantium double oven, all seamlessly connected to the main living areas. The great room opens effortlessly to the outdoor living spaces through fully retractable sliding doors, creating an ideal setting for gatherings of any size. Outdoor amenities rival those of a private resort, featuring a saltwater pool with pebble-tech finish and shallow lounging shelf, summer kitchen with natural gas Artisan grill, motorized patio screens, indoor/outdoor surround sound, and a luxury boat dock with electric cradle and Trex decking—perfect for enjoying the Butler Chain lifestyle year-round. Additional highlights include interior and exterior security systems, natural gas, city water, roof 2020, and a newer septic tank. Located just steps from downtown Windermere, residents enjoy a charming small-town atmosphere with farmers markets, cafés, local shops, and dining, while remaining only minutes from Restaurant Row and Orlando’s premier amenities. A rare opportunity to own a fully updated lakefront retreat in one of Central Florida’s most coveted communities.
Property Details
Price:
$3,725,000
MLS #:
O6370886
Status:
Active
Beds:
5
Baths:
4
Type:
Single Family
Subtype:
Single Family Residence
Subdivision:
LAKE BUTLER PARK PT REP
Neighborhood:
34786windermere
Listed Date:
Feb 5, 2026
Finished Sq Ft:
4,875
Total Sq Ft:
6,355
Lot Size:
25,329 sqft / 0.58 acres (approx)
Year Built:
1953
See this Listing
Schools
Interior
Appliances
Built-In Oven, Convection Oven, Dishwasher, Disposal, Gas Water Heater, Microwave, Refrigerator
Bathrooms
4 Full Bathrooms
Cooling
Central Air
Flooring
Engineered Hardwood, Tile, Hardwood
Heating
Electric
Interior Features
Ceiling Fan(s), High Ceilings, Kitchen/Family Room Combo, Living Room/Dining Room Combo, Open Floorplan, Primary Bedroom Main Floor, Solid Wood Cabinets, Split Bedroom, Stone Counters, Thermostat, Vaulted Ceiling(s), Walk-In Closet(s), Window Treatments
Laundry Features
Inside, Laundry Room
Levels
Two
Exterior
Architectural Style
Traditional
Attached Garage YN
1
Construction Materials
Block, Stucco
Covered Spaces
3
Direction Faces
Northeast
Exterior Features
Irrigation System, Lighting, Outdoor Grill, Rain Gutters, Sliding Doors
Fencing
Fenced
Garage Spaces
3
Lot Features
City Lot, Oversized Lot
Open Parking YN
1
Parking Features
Driveway, Garage Door Opener, Golf Cart Garage
Patio And Porch Features
Rear Porch
Roof
Shingle
View
Water
Waterfront Features
Lake Front, Lake – Chain of Lakes
Window Features
Blinds, Double Pane Windows, Shutters, Window Treatments
Financial
Tax Year
2024
Taxes
$21,723
Map
Community
- Address58 MAIN STREET WINDERMERE FL
- SubdivisionLAKE BUTLER PARK PT REP
- CityWINDERMERE
- CountyOrange
- Zip Code34786
Subdivisions in WINDERMERE
- ACREAGE AND UNREC
- ALADAR ON LAKE BUTLER
- ASHLIN FARK PH 2
- ASHLIN PARK PH 1
- ASHLIN PARK PH 2
- BELLA VITA ESTATES
- BELLARIA
- BELMERE VILLAGE
- BELMERE VILLAGE G-5
- BELMERE VILLAGE G2 48 65
- BELMERE VILLAGE G4 50 58
- BELMERE VILLAGE G5
- BELMERE VLG G2
- BUTLER BAY
- BUTLER RIDGE
- CARRINGTON
- CASA DEL LAGO REP
- CASABELLA
- CASABELLA PH 2
- CHAINE DE LAC
- CHAINE DU LAC
- CREEKS RUN
- DAVIS SHORES
- DOWN ACRES ESTATES
- DOWN POINT SUB
- DOWNS COVE CAMP SITES
- EDEN ISLE
- EDENS HAMMOCK
- ENCLAVE
- ENCLAVE AT WINDERMERE LANDING
- ENCLAVE/BERKSHIRE PARK B G H I
- ESTATES AT WINDERMERE
- FARMS
- GLENMUIR
- GLENMUIR 48 39
- GLENMUIR UT 02 51 42
- GOTHA TOWN
- ISLEWORTH
- ISLEWORTH 01 AMD
- KEENE’S POINTE
- KEENES POINTE
- KEENES POINTE 46/104
- KEENES POINTE UNIT 01
- KEENES POINTE UNIT 03 46/104
- KEENES POINTE UNIT 2
- KEENES POINTE UNIT 7
- KEENES POINTE UNIT 9
- KEENES POINTE UT 04 SEC 31 48 82
- KEENES POINTE UT 06 50 95
- LAKE BURDEN
- LAKE BURDEN SOUTH PH 2
- LAKE BURDEN SOUTH PH 2 #35 36
- LAKE BURDEN SOUTH PH I
- LAKE BUTLER ESTATES
- LAKE BUYNAK ESTATES
- LAKE CAWOOD ESTATES
- LAKE CAWOOD ESTS REP
- LAKE CRESENT RESERVE
- LAKE CYPRESS COVE PH 02
- LAKE DAVIS RESERVE
- LAKE DOWN COVE
- LAKE DOWN ESTATES
- LAKE HANCOCK SHORES
- LAKE ROPER POINTE
- LAKE SAWYER SOUTH
- LAKE SAWYER SOUTH PH 01
- LAKE SAWYER SOUTH PH 02
- LAKE SAWYER SOUTH PH 03
- LAKE SAWYER SOUTH PH 04
- LAKE SAWYER SOUTH PH 3
- LAKES
- LAKES OF WINDERMERE PH 1
- LAKES OF WINDERMERE PH 2A
- LAKES WINDERMERE PH 01 49 108
- LAKES/WINDERMERE PH 02A
- LAKES/WINDERMERE PH 04
- LAKES/WINDERMERE PH 3
- LAKES/WINDERMERE-LK REAMS TWHM
- LAKES/WINDERMERE-LK REAMS TWNH
- LAKES/WINDERMERE-PEACHTREE
- LAKESIDE VILLAGE TWNHMS
- LAKESIDE VILLAS
- LAKESIDE/LKS/WINDERMERE
- LAKESIDE/LKS/WINDERMERE CONDO
- LAKESIDE/LKS/WINDERMERE PH 10
- LAKESIDE/LKS/WINDERMERE PH 4
- LEGADO
- MARINA BAY ESTATES
- MARSH SUB
- MERRICK LANDING
- METCALF PARK REP
- OASIS COVE I/LAKESIDE VILLAGE PH 01
- OASIS COVE II/LAKESIDE VILLAGE
- OASIS COVE II/LAKESIDE VILLAGE PH
- OXFORD MOOR 47/30
- PALMS AT WINDERMERE
- PEACHTREE PARK
- PRESTON SQUARE
- PROVIDENCE
- PROVIDENCE PH 01 50 03
- PROVIDENCE PH 02
- PROVIDENCE PH 2
- RESERVE AT BELMERE PH 02 48 144
- RESERVE AT BELMERE PH 03 51 01
- RESERVE AT LAKE BUTLER
- RESERVE AT LAKE BUTLER SOUND
- RESERVE AT LAKE BUTLER SOUND 45/120
- RESERVE AT LAKE BUTLER SOUND UNIT 02
- RESERVE AT LAKE BUTLER SOUND UNIT 2
- RESERVE AT WINDERMERE
- RESERVE/BELMERE PH 04
- ROBERTS LANDING
- SADDLECREST AT WINDERMERE
- SANCTUARY/LKS/WINDERMERE
- SAWYER SHORES SUB
- SILVER WOODS
- SILVER WOODS PH 01
- SILVER WOODS PH 02
- SILVER WOODS PH 03A
- SILVER WOODS PH 04
- SILVER WOODS PH 3
- SOUTHBRIDGE VILLAGE
- STILLWATER XINGS PRCL SC-13 #2
- SUMMERPORT
- SUMMERPORT BEACH
- SUMMERPORT PH 02
- SUMMERPORT PH 03
- SUMMERPORT PH 04 C E F & G
- SUMMERPORT PH 05
- SUMMERPORT TRL
- SUNSET BAY
- TENNYSON PK/SUMMERPORT
- TILDENS GROVE
- TILDENS GROVE PH 01 47/65
- TUSCANY RIDGE 50 141
- VINEYARDS/HORIZON WEST PH 2A
- VINEYARDS/HORIZONS WEST PH 4
- WATERFORD POINTE
- WATERSIDE
- WATERSTONE
- WATERSTONE A D E F G H J L
- WAUSEON RIDGE
- WEATHERSTONE ON LAKE OLIVIA
- WEST LAKE BUTLER ESTATES
- WEST POINT COMMONS
- WESTOVER CLUB
- WESTOVER CLUB PH 02 47/71
- WESTOVER CLUB PH 02 REP
- WESTOVER RESERVE PH 02
- WESTSIDE VILLAGE
- WHITNEY ISLES / BELMERE PH 02
- WHITNEY ISLES AT BELMERE
- WHITNEY ISLES/BELMERE PH 02
- WICKHAM PARK
- WICKHAM PARK 04 05 06 09 10 11 12 01
- WINDDERMERE POINTE
- WINDERMERE
- WINDERMERE DOWNS
- WINDERMERE GRANDE
- WINDERMERE ISLE
- WINDERMERE ISLE PH 2
- WINDERMERE ISLE-PH 2
- WINDERMERE LNDGS PH 02
- WINDERMERE RESERVE
- WINDERMERE SOUND
- WINDERMERE SOUND PH 2
- WINDERMERE TERRACE
- WINDERMERE TOWN
- WINDERMERE TOWN REP
- WINDERMERE TRAILS
- WINDERMERE TRAILS PHASE 1C 80/15 LOT 113
- WINDERMERE TRAILS PHASE 4A
- WINDERMERE TRLS PH 1B
- WINDERMERE TRLS PH 1C
- WINDERMERE TRLS PH 3A
- WINDERMERE TRLS PH 3B
- WINDERMERE TRLS PH 4B
- WINDERMERE TRLS PH IA
- WINDERMERE TRLS PRCL 3
- WINDSOR HILL
Market Summary
Current real estate data for Single Family in WINDERMERE as of Apr 24, 2026
289
Single Family Listed
97
Avg DOM
459
Avg $ / SqFt
$2,232,724
Avg List Price
Property Summary
- Located in the LAKE BUTLER PARK PT REP subdivision, 58 MAIN STREET WINDERMERE FL is a Single Family for sale in WINDERMERE, FL, 34786. It is listed for $3,725,000 and features 5 beds, 4 baths, and has approximately 4,875 square feet of living space, and was originally constructed in 1953. The current price per square foot is $764. The average price per square foot for Single Family listings in WINDERMERE is $459. The average listing price for Single Family in WINDERMERE is $2,232,724. To schedule a showing of MLS#o6370886 at 58 MAIN STREET in WINDERMERE, FL, contact your CENTURY 21 Carioti agent at 800-783-8847.
Similar Listings Nearby
Courtesy of LPT REALTY, LLC. Disclaimer: All data relating to real estate for sale on this page comes from the Broker Reciprocity (BR) of the Orlando/Tampa – FL. Detailed information about real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than CENTURY 21 Carioti include the name of the listing broker. Neither the listing company nor CENTURY 21 Carioti shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints and shall be held totally harmless. The Broker providing this data believes it to be correct, but advises interested parties to confirm any item before relying on it in a purchase decision. Copyright 2026. Orlando/Tampa – FL. All rights reserved. 58 MAIN STREET
WINDERMERE, FL

Recent Comments